what happens if a plane is tail heavy.

irekkin

New member
what happens when your plane is tail heavy. how will it act and will it fly. also ,what is meant by high alpha.tia
 

c172ae

Pro plane crasher
If the plane is tailheavy, it will be very twitchy and hard to control. High alpha is if the wing has a high angle of attack.
 

Craftydan

Hostage Taker of Quads
Staff member
Moderator
Mentor
Effectively, it controls how the plane will enter a stall, but that greatly affects slow speed charictersitics. As the plane looses airspeed it looses lift, and tail heavy/nose heavy will determine whether the plane can self-correct, or just make the problem worse.

In nose heavy, as the plane looses lift and approaches stall speed, the nose will drop (hence, nose heavy). This will increase airspeed, and as long as you don't run out of altitude or counter it with control, it will avoid a full stall and find a happy glideslope.

In a tail heavy plane, as it looses lift and approaches stall speed, the tail will drop -- the worst possible thing that could happen! You'll loose airspeed and it will rapildy move into a full stall. you can counter this with control, but unlike the nose heavy plane where it's easy to find a happy glideslope, the happy point will change with airspeed. So as it goes into a stall, you command more down, the nose drops, it picks up more speed, and it now wants less down, so you have to command less, but then it looses speed, so you command more, but now . . . and it really acts twitchy and hard to control.

I suppose the thing to look out for on an untrimmed airframe, get it straight and level, and gently reduce the throttle. as the plane *slows*, does it's nose ease down or the tail or does it just start to sink?
 

irekkin

New member
thanks fellas
the reason I asked about tail heavy and high alpha is I'm learning how to fly on my own, flying a swappable nutball. the video said it could be tail heavy and to pay attention to the CG. I just didn't realize how important it was. that and flying in the wind is not the way to go. man, I had no idea foam could be that tough. I have slammed that plane so many times it ain't funny and it still wants to fly. it just needs some one who knows how. lol
 

Craftydan

Hostage Taker of Quads
Staff member
Moderator
Mentor
Bad things. Bad things happen which generally lead to hull loss.

Usually this is true, and for those who don't know what it looks like, that usually becomes almost always . . .

. . . but, many pilots flying stunts and 3D will use tail-heavy balance to more easily pop into high alpha and hover attitudes. These are slow speed maneuvers, and they're hard to maintain at any balance forward of neutral. Frankly they can be hard to maintain at tail-heavy balance, but it's a bit easier because you're not forcing the plane into an attitude it doesn't want to already be in.


My first flight with my Bloody Wonder was HORRIBLY tail-heavy, and on takeoff and climb out, since the throttle was strong and I was keeping the airspeed up, it was flying like the untrimmed airframe it was. Hooray!!! It flies!!!

. . . until I started to slow down. I gently backed off on throttle and it immediately slipped into high alpha. WHY?!? Oh! Balance!!!!

Crap.

It flies, but how am I going to get this down?!?

The trick was to keep the airspeed high enough to keep control, and low enough it would descend. I took it up a few mistakes trimmed at a higher throttle, and learned how to safely, slowly descend before the ground became involved. It came down in one piece with nothing more than grass stains, but it was tricky, and the airframe is pretty light and hardy.

One more reason to do a few glide tosses before you maiden, to see how it stalls from 6' up, as opposed to 60'.
 

Stradawhovious

"That guy"
If you're a novice, the following usually always applies... "A nose heavy plane flies poorly, a tail heavy plane flies once."


Ask me how I know.
 

Tactical Ex

Senior Member
So long as it isn't a flying wing I have been able to land tail heavy planes without too much incident so that I can fix the CG. Landing at 1/2 throttle is a heart pounding adventure though! Watching a BW land tail first is an interesting sight as well.
 

Shufty

Senior Member
Usually this is true, and for those who don't know what it looks like, that usually becomes almost always . . .

. . . but, many pilots flying stunts and 3D will use tail-heavy balance to more easily pop into high alpha and hover attitudes. These are slow speed maneuvers, and they're hard to maintain at any balance forward of neutral. Frankly they can be hard to maintain at tail-heavy balance, but it's a bit easier because you're not forcing the plane into an attitude it doesn't want to already be in.


My first flight with my Bloody Wonder was HORRIBLY tail-heavy, and on takeoff and climb out, since the throttle was strong and I was keeping the airspeed up, it was flying like the untrimmed airframe it was. Hooray!!! It flies!!!

. . . until I started to slow down. I gently backed off on throttle and it immediately slipped into high alpha. WHY?!? Oh! Balance!!!!

Crap.

It flies, but how am I going to get this down?!?

The trick was to keep the airspeed high enough to keep control, and low enough it would descend. I took it up a few mistakes trimmed at a higher throttle, and learned how to safely, slowly descend before the ground became involved. It came down in one piece with nothing more than grass stains, but it was tricky, and the airframe is pretty light and hardy.

One more reason to do a few glide tosses before you maiden, to see how it stalls from 6' up, as opposed to 60'.

Haha, yeah, I meant from a beginners point of view Dan :)

I too had the same experience with my Bloody Wonder, it sure does get exciting when it's tail heavy!
 

Craftydan

Hostage Taker of Quads
Staff member
Moderator
Mentor
Haha, yeah, I meant from a beginners point of view Dan :)

I too had the same experience with my Bloody Wonder, it sure does get exciting when it's tail heavy!

Understood Shufty, and from that perspective I completely agree.

I was just being a touch OCD and expanding on your thought -- Didn't see anything wrong with your post and wasn't trying to say that either :)

If you think a tail heavy BW is "exciting", you should try it on a versa . . . better yet . . . don't ;)
 

SlimJim

Junior Member
I have been having problems getting my cg far enough forward on my bloody wonder. My 850 mah 3s is as far forward as it will go and the cg is about 3/4 of an inch behind the spar. Is this close enough or do you have any tips for getting it farther forward?
 

PHugger

Church Meal Expert
Two things come to mind -
Figure out how to lighten the tail
Add weight to the nose



Best regards,
PCH
 

Craftydan

Hostage Taker of Quads
Staff member
Moderator
Mentor
SlimJim,

PHugger has it spot on. learning to lighten a tail is something you'll pick up eventually -- it's far easier to do it while you're building -- but adding weight is something anyone can do anytime.

For adding weight to the nose, a couple of simple options -- Install a spinner, and add sinkers.

For the BW, you could add a 2"-ish spinner to the motor/prop. It'll look nice and move the CG forward. They usually have a back-plate that mounts between the motor and the prop, and then the spinner's cone slips over the prop and bolts to the backplate. they aren't terribly heavy, but because it's the farthest point forward on the airframe, they add quite a bit to the balance. Downside is you'll have to visit a LHS or pick up one online (I usually buy mine online from "value hobby").

A spinner will help tremendously, but 3/4" behind the spar is REALLY bad (What size motor are you using?). Slipping a few fishing sinkers behind the firewall will take care of the rest. Get it to balance with the battery on the CG (so you can put a bigger battery on in the future), then add a little hot-glue in to hold the sinkers in place. nice part of this is it only requires a trip to a local store and it's cheap. the down side is it adds weight forcing you to fly faster to keep above the stall speed.

Get the balance and you're ready to tear up the sky :)

BTW, Welcome to the forum!
 

SlimJim

Junior Member
Crafydan,

I am using the blue wonder setup because of a fiasco I had with the beef pack and a duster... I did manage to get the cg almost to that spar and it flew decent.(at least decent to me) I put a video of it on the flitetest fans facebook page. I had to velcro the battery sideways as far forward as it would go along with a low voltage alarm and some rubber bands. I will try the fishing sinkers and see how that works. Thanks for the welcome!

Slimjim
 

Craftydan

Hostage Taker of Quads
Staff member
Moderator
Mentor
yeah, that would explain it.

Nothing wrong with a blue wonder for power, but it is pretty lightweight -- the typical motors for the Bloody Wonder run about 1.5-2 times heavier than the 24g motors.
 

SlimJim

Junior Member
Do you think I should try and make myself a removable weight pod. That way if I every decide to go up to the beef I dont have worry about being nose heavy.