AeroForge3D Sport Flyer V1: 900 mm 3D printable sport plane, plus our CG notes

AeroForge3D

New member
Hi all, this is AeroForge3D. We design 3D printable RC planes. This is our own product, and we sell the files (link at the bottom). We also wanted to share the CG work and print notes, because they apply to most printed sport planes. We are still learning a lot, and we welcome feedback.

Flight clip:

01-IMG_0026.jpg

03-IMG_0175.jpg

04-IMG_0174.jpg


The plane
- 900 mm span, 645 mm long, wing cube loading about 11.2
- Intermediate sport plane, not a trainer and not a 3D plane. It has flown (clip above). Fast, quiet, and fine in 5+ mph wind.
- Recommended setup: Radial 1806 2280 kV motor, 20 to 25 A ESC, four 5 g micro servos, 1000 mAh 3S LiPo, 6 x 4 prop, 1 mm wire pushrods

Where the CG goes, and why we give a band instead of a mark
- AVL (vortex lattice) puts the neutral point 230 to 232 mm aft of the spinner tip (230.1 with the fuselage modeled, 232.4 without).
- USAF Digital DATCOM puts it at about 213.5 mm. Its methods come mostly from full size aircraft data, and this wing runs at about Re 1.7 x 10^5, so we treat DATCOM as a pessimistic bound.
- First flight CG: 39 to 46 mm behind the wing leading edge, which is 210 to 217 mm from the spinner tip. Measure at the wing root with the plane level. Start at 42 mm. Never go aft of 51 mm (222 mm from the spinner tip).
- Why start there: only 210 to 213 mm is ahead of the DATCOM number.
- The vertical tail volume is modest (0.027 exposed). If it feels pitchy, move the CG forward before you touch the tail, and don't shrink the fin.

Print notes
- 0.16 mm layers, 15% infill, no supports, parts printed flat on the plate. PLA or LW-PLA.
- About 16 hours and about 325 g of filament.
- If you slice it yourself instead of using the Bambu Lab example project, turn on thin wall detection with the Arachne wall generator.
- Expect some knife cleanup on the joins. We use super glue gel plus hobby tape on the joints, and low temp hot glue for the control horns (go easy so the PLA does not warp).

Question for you: if you have compared AVL, XFLR5 or an online CG calculator against where your own printed plane actually balanced well, how far apart were they?

We will answer questions here.

Files: https://www.printables.com/model/1895562-sport-flyer-v1-3d-printed-rc-plane-900-mm-sport-ae
 

telnar1236

Master member
Question for you: if you have compared AVL, XFLR5 or an online CG calculator against where your own printed plane actually balanced well, how far apart were they?
Files: https://www.printables.com/model/1895562-sport-flyer-v1-3d-printed-rc-plane-900-mm-sport-ae
For conventional designs with straight wings all of those options are great and compare very well with reality. If you have a more complex layout with, for example, a lifting fuselage, then the calculation becomes more questionable.
 

AeroForge3D

New member
For conventional designs with straight wings all of those options are great and compare very well with reality. If you have a more complex layout with, for example, a lifting fuselage, then the calculation becomes more questionable.
Thanks, that is good to hear. It is part of why we give a first flight band of 210 to 217 mm from the spinner tip, never past 222, rather than one mark: the tools disagreed by more than we expected (AVL 230 to 232 mm for the neutral point, DATCOM about 213.5).
 

telnar1236

Master member
Thanks, that is good to hear. It is part of why we give a first flight band of 210 to 217 mm from the spinner tip, never past 222, rather than one mark: the tools disagreed by more than we expected (AVL 230 to 232 mm for the neutral point, DATCOM about 213.5).
Have you tested to that full CG range? Predictions without flight testing to back it up are just predictions. You also very much want to be flying with a CG ahead of the NP. If it flies well at a CG of 217 mm, that tells you the DATCOM prediction is wrong (or includes a stability margin already). I've never used DATCOM myself, but I know AVL and XFLR5 predictions are quite reliable
 

AeroForge3D

New member
Quick update with the assembly notes from the listing:
Joints: super glue gel plus hobby tape, with some knife cleanup on the joins.
Control horns: low temperature hot glue, used sparingly so the PLA does not warp.
Tail pushrods: 1 mm wire, through two small holes drilled in the fuselage.
Print: 0.16 mm layers, 15% infill, no supports, parts flat on the plate. If you are not using the Bambu Lab example project, turn on thin wall detection with the Arachne wall generator.
Thanks to everyone who weighed in on the CG question. If you have built a printed plane where the calculator and the real balance point disagreed, we would like to hear about it.
 
Last edited:

AeroForge3D

New member
Have you tested to that full CG range? Predictions without flight testing to back it up are just predictions. You also very much want to be flying with a CG ahead of the NP. If it flies well at a CG of 217 mm, that tells you the DATCOM prediction is wrong (or includes a stability margin already). I've never used DATCOM myself, but I know AVL and XFLR5 predictions are quite reliable
Good question, and fair point. All of our flights so far have been at around 50 mm behind the leading edge (about 221 mm from the spinner tip). We haven't flight tested the rest of the band yet, so the numbers forward of that are predictions, not tested ones. That's why we say start at 42 mm and never past 51 mm. Every number in the band is ahead of the AVL neutral point (230 to 232 mm). We agree that AVL and XFLR5 are probably closer to reality than DATCOM. We used DATCOM as a pessimistic bound because its methods come mostly from full size aircraft data. Once we fly more CG points, we'll post where it balanced best.
 

telnar1236

Master member
Good question, and fair point. All of our flights so far have been at around 50 mm behind the leading edge (about 221 mm from the spinner tip). We haven't flight tested the rest of the band yet, so the numbers forward of that are predictions, not tested ones. That's why we say start at 42 mm and never past 51 mm. Every number in the band is ahead of the AVL neutral point (230 to 232 mm). We agree that AVL and XFLR5 are probably closer to reality than DATCOM. We used DATCOM as a pessimistic bound because its methods come mostly from full size aircraft data. Once we fly more CG points, we'll post where it balanced best.
Yeah, the plane flying at that CG is conclusive evidence that DATCOM is way off for neutral point. I suspect there may be some unintended margin built into the calculation as this should not be substantially different at RC scales and full scale for a conventional wing like this or the tool may just be intentionally very conservative.
 

AeroForge3D

New member
Our CG explainer video is up, for anyone who wants the long version of this thread:

@telnar1236 thanks, that lines up with how we read it too. We can't say for sure why DATCOM puts the neutral point so far forward. One thing the video looks at is Reynolds number: the Sport Flyer flies at about 120,000 to 180,000, and the NACA airfoil data behind DATCOM was mostly taken between 3 and 9 million. That may be part of it, or the method may simply be conservative, as you said.

Two things from the video we haven't posted here yet:
- The usual 25% of chord rule of thumb (the one we cite from Flite Test) would put the CG about 37 mm behind the leading edge on this wing. That is a static margin of about 15.5% against AVL: very stable, but more nose heavy than this plane needs.
- The chord is about 147 mm, so each 1 mm of CG moves the static margin by about two thirds of a percent. That is why a few millimeters matter on a plane this size.

It also walks through balancing on the bench. If you spot anything we got wrong, please tell us here.

The files are on Cults3D as well: https://cults3d.com/en/3d-model/game/sport-flyer-v1-radio-control-rc-plane