With my less than stellar flying skills the spine method hasn't held up to rough landings. I'm more concerned with the front - a rough landing in the corsair ripped cowl clean off 😆 🤣 I've had quite a few heavy landings (even cartwheels!) with my
@Niez13 hellcat and fw190 as well as my 109 and p36 all with not much more than some wrinkles in the end of a wing! The box in the back has worked out very well in my design, but I fully respect the spine method for a lighter airframe (I actually have since added quite a bit of weight to the spar of my corsair! )
Yeah, the tail generally doesn't need much strength, but there are definitely some scenarios in which it would be beneficial (in fact I'm working on a design right now using the box method. I know what you mean about the front -- I think
@MiniacRC has the right idea with the removable front on his mini p-47, but that's hard to integrate with a hatch. Anyway, hopefully someday someone'll come up with something to solve the problem.