So last night I texted my buddy with the warp quad about FGA's performance and we decided if the weather was nice this morning we'd try to do a bit of flying.
I hadn't re-assembled the hex since I got back from Flite Fest, and in fact hadn't flown it since a gentle crash into the soybeans took out two props (and I didn't feel like walking back to my tent for more since my wife and daughter were waiting for me to finish off my last batteries and head home.) So I put it back together. Did some basic bench testing and confirmed things seemed ready to go.
Then this morning while I was waiting for him to show up I decided to do a quick front yard test flight just to make sure it was working well. Uh oh. Suddenly the hex was doing the same thing my twitchity 230 has been doing. Suddenly glitching in the air and dropping an arm then falling out of the sky
Crud.
Well, my emax 250 should be good to go. No RX on it right now so I grabbed the one off my knuckle and put it on since I had just taken it off the 250 to put on the knuckle for flite fest. At least it still flies as well as normal. Though with the 5" "indestructible" props it feels sluggish and I'm still not at all happy with the tune (Just can not get luxfloat tuned to my liking...or any other CF PID controllers, really getting frustrated with it.) But at least something can fly.
My friend showed up and we tried to debug the hex and the 230 since they've both doing the same thing with one or more motors suddenly loosing power for no obvious reason. The hex has logging enabled so that will help rule out FC/RX issues, but the quad only has 4 motors to deal with so it's easier to debug - we started with the quad.
Did a few test flights and confirmed that it always seems to be the right rear motor that was cutting out. That's one of the unprotected KISS so while it seemed questionable that the ESC could be the issue as it still lit up and appeared to work...we decided to swap it out with a spare I have as the first test. Whoops, forgot to solder the oneshot jumper. Ok, now it flies. Hey, feels pretty good...maybe it was a bad ESC after...oh wait...there it goes again
Well nuts.
So let's try swapping the two rear motors to see if the problem follows the motor. Solder solder solder....solder solder solder...ok, motors swapped. Test flight. Wow! Feels great! Oh wait...there it goes. And it followed the motor. Well, that seems to answer that. Will have to tear apart that motor and see what's up, I'm guessing I finally burned out a winding running those DYS 1806 on 6x4.5" props.
At least that finally explains the issues I've been having with that quad for a month. Hopefully. Don't think I'll replace just that motor. Think I may wait until I can afford some 2204's for it and replace them all since I've been so unhappy with the DYS. Then I can build some more FT mini planes with the other 3 motors (Just ordered a 5 pack of firewalls last night, what a happy coincidence!)
So the hex...what's going on there. It was a gentle crash at FF. I was surprised it even broke any props. Let's try flying it again to collect some logs and see if it's always the same arm that drops. Oh wait...it's flying great now! Really great, just like always! Did a few flips and rolls and laps around the front yard...seems great. Ok let's take the hex and the 250 up to the field!
Got to the field, put the 250 into the air for some FPV...and crashed almost immediately...something didn't feel right. No damage, put the pack back on and tried it LOS to see what was up...throttled up for a flip...and it stopped responding then a second later (as it should) started beeping and fell out of the sky. Seem to have lost RX. Grrr. Checked things out and all looked ok...but the RX power light was going on and off. Re-connected it, with fresh tape on the connection to keep it secure...seemed good. Test flight again. Lost control almost immediately and zoomed into a wood pole.
Good news, the "indestructible" props are looking like they can loose the quotes and deserve the name. Wonder if surveilzone will ever send the the rest of my order they said they shipped almost two months ago.
But something is definitely going funky with the RX on that setup. It's one of my homemade ones and has never given me any issues...at least not until the last flight of the knuckle in combat at FF. I had originally thought it was a battery sagging...but then started to think it may have been RX lockouts from so much RF in the air...now I'm thinking something may have happened to this one. Will have to tear it apart and see what's up. Oh well.
Let's fly the hex! Feel good, little flip action...maybe I'll land and put on the goggles. Oh wait. Arm suddenly drops and falls from the sky
The gremlin is back
Did some ground tests and the right rear motor is making a bit of a clicking sound that comes and goes and it's ESC is running WAY hotter than the other 5. Something is definitely up with that arm. Not sure what yet...will have to take that motor apart and see what's what I guess.
So not a very good day for flying for me
Didn't even bring the mobius figuring that would be asking for trouble 
Guess I've got some motors to take apart and see what's going on with them.
I hadn't re-assembled the hex since I got back from Flite Fest, and in fact hadn't flown it since a gentle crash into the soybeans took out two props (and I didn't feel like walking back to my tent for more since my wife and daughter were waiting for me to finish off my last batteries and head home.) So I put it back together. Did some basic bench testing and confirmed things seemed ready to go.
Then this morning while I was waiting for him to show up I decided to do a quick front yard test flight just to make sure it was working well. Uh oh. Suddenly the hex was doing the same thing my twitchity 230 has been doing. Suddenly glitching in the air and dropping an arm then falling out of the sky
Well, my emax 250 should be good to go. No RX on it right now so I grabbed the one off my knuckle and put it on since I had just taken it off the 250 to put on the knuckle for flite fest. At least it still flies as well as normal. Though with the 5" "indestructible" props it feels sluggish and I'm still not at all happy with the tune (Just can not get luxfloat tuned to my liking...or any other CF PID controllers, really getting frustrated with it.) But at least something can fly.
My friend showed up and we tried to debug the hex and the 230 since they've both doing the same thing with one or more motors suddenly loosing power for no obvious reason. The hex has logging enabled so that will help rule out FC/RX issues, but the quad only has 4 motors to deal with so it's easier to debug - we started with the quad.
Did a few test flights and confirmed that it always seems to be the right rear motor that was cutting out. That's one of the unprotected KISS so while it seemed questionable that the ESC could be the issue as it still lit up and appeared to work...we decided to swap it out with a spare I have as the first test. Whoops, forgot to solder the oneshot jumper. Ok, now it flies. Hey, feels pretty good...maybe it was a bad ESC after...oh wait...there it goes again
Well nuts.
So let's try swapping the two rear motors to see if the problem follows the motor. Solder solder solder....solder solder solder...ok, motors swapped. Test flight. Wow! Feels great! Oh wait...there it goes. And it followed the motor. Well, that seems to answer that. Will have to tear apart that motor and see what's up, I'm guessing I finally burned out a winding running those DYS 1806 on 6x4.5" props.
At least that finally explains the issues I've been having with that quad for a month. Hopefully. Don't think I'll replace just that motor. Think I may wait until I can afford some 2204's for it and replace them all since I've been so unhappy with the DYS. Then I can build some more FT mini planes with the other 3 motors (Just ordered a 5 pack of firewalls last night, what a happy coincidence!)
So the hex...what's going on there. It was a gentle crash at FF. I was surprised it even broke any props. Let's try flying it again to collect some logs and see if it's always the same arm that drops. Oh wait...it's flying great now! Really great, just like always! Did a few flips and rolls and laps around the front yard...seems great. Ok let's take the hex and the 250 up to the field!
Got to the field, put the 250 into the air for some FPV...and crashed almost immediately...something didn't feel right. No damage, put the pack back on and tried it LOS to see what was up...throttled up for a flip...and it stopped responding then a second later (as it should) started beeping and fell out of the sky. Seem to have lost RX. Grrr. Checked things out and all looked ok...but the RX power light was going on and off. Re-connected it, with fresh tape on the connection to keep it secure...seemed good. Test flight again. Lost control almost immediately and zoomed into a wood pole.
Good news, the "indestructible" props are looking like they can loose the quotes and deserve the name. Wonder if surveilzone will ever send the the rest of my order they said they shipped almost two months ago.
But something is definitely going funky with the RX on that setup. It's one of my homemade ones and has never given me any issues...at least not until the last flight of the knuckle in combat at FF. I had originally thought it was a battery sagging...but then started to think it may have been RX lockouts from so much RF in the air...now I'm thinking something may have happened to this one. Will have to tear it apart and see what's up. Oh well.
Let's fly the hex! Feel good, little flip action...maybe I'll land and put on the goggles. Oh wait. Arm suddenly drops and falls from the sky
Did some ground tests and the right rear motor is making a bit of a clicking sound that comes and goes and it's ESC is running WAY hotter than the other 5. Something is definitely up with that arm. Not sure what yet...will have to take that motor apart and see what's what I guess.
So not a very good day for flying for me
Guess I've got some motors to take apart and see what's going on with them.