Prop Size ?'s ; 2 blade vs 3 blade

alan0043

Elite member
Hi Everyone,

I have a few questions about prop sizes. I am thinking about going from a 2 blade prop to a 3 blade prop. Please tell me if I have this correct. If you go from a 2 blade prop to a 3 blade prop, you need to decrease the diameter of the 3 blade prop by 1". Example ; 10" x 4.5 x 2 then go to 9" x 4.5 x 3. Is this correct ? Is there a down side of going to a 3 blade prop ? Is there something I could be missing ?

Open to all input,
Al
 

Merv

Moderator
Moderator
...If you go from a 2 blade prop to a 3 blade prop, you need to decrease the diameter of the 3 blade prop by 1"...
Yes, that is the general rule of thumb.
I suspect there is a large safety factor built into that suggestion. When trying a new prop size or battery cell count, I prefer to use a watt meter. Another test. Give it a 10 second run at full throttle. Then stop & test the temperature by touching the motor, warm is OK but if it's too hot to hold, STOP, the prop is too big. If it passes, try a 30 second run. It is passes, try a 60 second run. If that pass, go for a fly.

... Is there a down side of going to a 3 blade prop ?...
Not much. More blades reduce the efficiency slightly. Maybe 5% or so.
 
Last edited:

RickHunter

Elite member
Why is that? It doesn't really make sense because there is way more blade length.
In short.
3 blades (or more) produce more drag. So more current draw, more heat , and more battery draw. You also usually get more thrust (not speed) with 3 blade.
2 blade means less drag, and less resistant. Higher top speed and less heat and power draw.

There is a ton of stuff on the internet that will go into much more detail than this about the differences, but this is the absolute basics.
 
Last edited:

31SamCoMi

Active member
I heard about a prop that was one blade and a weight one the other side to balence it. It was highly efficient.
1793637271273.jpeg
 

RickHunter

Elite member
I heard about a prop that was one blade and a weight one the other side to balence it. It was highly efficient. View attachment 261058
Yes there was a few in some old school planes. But due to there cost, and the fact that motors quickly became so much more powerful and the efficiency of them not really needed, they never really caught on. I believe they are stilled used in a few control line airplanes.
 

Merv

Moderator
Moderator
Why is that? It doesn't really make sense because there is way more blade length.
Why reduce an inch?
It has to do with the area of the propeller arc. If you kept the same prop diameter you would be increasing the pulling force of the prop by 1/3rd. Which would overload the motor if you were already at the max. Let's consider going from a 2 blade 8 inch prop to a 3 blade 7 inch prop. The 8 inch prop is going to have a prop arc of about 50 sq in, while the prop arc of the 7 inch is about 38.5 sq in. About 31% less area, which is offset by the extra blade. Remember, a rule of thumb is not an exact measurement, it's just general guidance to get you in the right ball park.
 

Merv

Moderator
Moderator
I heard about a prop that was one blade and a weight one the other side to balence it. It was highly efficient.
More efficient, yes, but the increase in efficiency is small, not worth the squeeze. Why more efficient, it has cleaner air to bite into. The more blades you add, the less clean air. Each blade causes turbulence that the other blades have to deal with.
 
Last edited:

RickHunter

Elite member
One great and relatively cheap investment you might think of down the line is a rc watt meter ($20-$40). It takes most the guess work out. It really comes in handy as your fleet starts to grow. For example, my Turbo Timber Evolution comes with a 11inch three blade propeller, using my watt meter I found that a 13 x 4 propeller was a much better fit for it, and only use that size now. I could tell the proformance difference in the air right away along with a longer flight time as well. I fly/live over 5000 feet high (thinner air bigger propellers usally), so the watt meter helps me find a good fit for different planes. I know you can do the math to figure some of this stuff out too, but that makes my brain hurt. 😬
 

31SamCoMi

Active member
One great and relatively cheap investment you might think of down the line is a rc watt meter ($20-$40). It takes most the guess work out. It really comes in handy as your fleet starts to grow. For example, my Turbo Timber Evolution comes with a 11inch three blade propeller, using my watt meter I found that a 13 x 4 propeller was a much better fit for it, and only use that size now. I could tell the proformance difference in the air right away along with a longer flight time as well. I fly/live over 5000 feet high (thinner air bigger propellers usally), so the watt meter helps me find a good fit for different planes. I know you can do the math to figure some of this stuff out too, but that makes my brain hurt. 😬
I'm not sure how they work. Does it work so it compensates for the thinner air?
 

RickHunter

Elite member
I'm not sure how they work. Does it work so it compensates for the thinner air?
They show you the amps, watts, and voltage that you system is outputting. It plugs in between your battery and esc. For example if your 2212-1250kv 496watt motor with a 30amp esc has a 9x4.5 propeller on it, and it pulls 18amps, at 220watt, then you know you are in the green with this power setup. You can actually put a bigger propeller and try again. If the watt meter shows 28amps, 450 watts with that setup you need to go smaller propeller. THIS IS JUST AN EXAMPLE NOT WHAT YOUR SETUP IS ACTUALLY PRODUCING.
For me, being that I live at high altitude with thinner air, it allows me to see what best efficiency to use in the thin air. For example my 13x4 propeller does great here, but if I was at sea level with thicker air it would pry pull too mqny watts and/or amps, so I would pry have to put a smaller propeller on my plane at sea level compared to higher altitude. I have found that at my altitude I usually run a one inch bigger propeller here than I would at sea level to get the same proformance.
For the most part, a watt meter will take most of the guess work out and you will know you have the best proformance out of your setup.
 

RickHunter

Elite member
How much do factors change when using a slow fly (sf) prop?
Slow flyer propellers provide better low throttle thrust and low speed proformance. Great for park flyers and low speed planes. But they do draw quite a bit more amperage than the stiffer thin props (apc). And you don't want to use them on any higher speed planes.
I personally do not use any SF propellers on my setups anymore. There is absolutely nothing wrong with SF props, it's just a personally preference. In fact if your new and have some slower park flyers they will work fabulous on those, especially when your just putting around getting the feel of things.