Scale Build Off: Curtiss Robin

rcspaceflight

creator of virtual planes
Brief Backstory: For the longest time I've been wanting to get into building with balsa. To be perfectly honest, a balsa kit is a bit out of my price range and cutting out balsa pieces from plans seems both time consuming, and still a touch expensive. So I've decided to experiment with a new build material and method. Bamboo Skewers. I can afford bamboo skewers.

The New Style: Bamboo and Paper. Stick building. Pretty much the balsa route with the clear down side of not being able to do anything other than stick building. My airfoil is going to be the "FT style" and blocky. My covering is going to be printer paper. Why? Because I can print off the plans, glue the bamboo skewers directly onto the plans, and it's already covered. :D

Pros and Cons: Bamboo skewers are cheap. I estimate that this build will be slightly more expensive than Dollar Tree Foam Board, but cheaper than balsa. Even though I will have a paper covering, it should still last a lot longer than a DTFB plane. My control surfaces are going to be taped on with packing tape, which makes them easier to do and without the problems of DTFB planes. This should be a much faster build than a balsa plane, but slightly longer than a DTFB plane. One big downside is the limitations of "stick building". I can not cut out perfect airfoils. I'm limited to a bunch of straight lines.

Why the Curtiss Robin?: I was struggling with deciding what plane to base this build off of. I want something simple just to test the new build method. A Cub seemed too... obvious(?). A Das Ugly Stick seemed too... ugly. A Stuka or Corsiar seemed too complicated as a test build. Mostly I went with the Curtiss Robin because it's a very simple plane that you don't see much of. Plus it's what Douglas Corrigan flew from Los Angels, to New York City, to Dublin Ireland.

540x329xCORRIGAN-Douglas-Wrong-Way-with-his-Curtiss-Robin-NX9243.-at-Floyd-bennet-Field-July-1938.jpg.pagespeed.ic.r10UyRgKwX.jpg


Plans so far: As much as I'd love to fully mock up the plane in Sketchup, it seems redundant because all I really need to do is draw lines to show where I want to glue the bamboo skewers. I'm going to add "X" braces between the airfoil ribs and the fuselage is going to be a lot of "X"s for strength. I've decided for the aileron control surfaces I'm going to make them flat instead of copying the airfoil for them. Making them flat will help them flex better because it will better stay out of it's own way.

Curtiss Robin 01.jpg

Curtiss Robin 02.jpg

I wanted to be further along before sharing this build, but the entry deadline is a month away and I can't see myself building it until closer to nice weather. (I still fully plan on completing my first entry. Again, I don't see the point in building until I can fly.)
 

rcspaceflight

creator of virtual planes
It's actually nice out and it looks like it's going to stay that way. I better hurry up and get something ready to fly. I hope this will be a quick build so I might as well start this year off with this little bird.

I'm still finishing the plans and figuring out the landing gear. I do want scale landing gear. But I'm compromising with the wing struts. They're supposed to have a bend/joint in them but I'm making them straight.
Curtiss Robin 04.jpg

Another compromise is the engine/nose. I 3D modeled the motor I plan on using and the prop isn't quite in the right place, but motors vary and it leaves the plans open to work with different sized motors.
Curtiss Robin 03.jpg

I actually prefer the look of the OX-5:
curtiss-robin-with-ox-5.jpg


But I'm pretty much going with the original(?):
Robin01.jpg


Basically I'm going with what is easiest which is actually more of a mix between the two.
 
Last edited:

rcspaceflight

creator of virtual planes
I just started building and part of me wants to let the glue set so I can test for strength before I go further with the build.

Supplies:
P1250548.JPG

Dry fit:
P1250549.JPG

Glued in place: The easy thing about this building method is that I am gluing the bamboo skewers directly to the plans. No tracing out plans and it's skinned by the plans. The benefits of balsa but cheaper and I get to skip a few steps.
P1250550.JPG

Before I continue building I want to let the super glue set completely to ensure that the method will work. Currently there is flex at the skewer joints. Which will make the plane a failure unless the glue can stiffen it up once fully dry.